Monday, July 6, 2015

"Dear Entrants, ..." - Part Three

I recently did two days of judging at a nearby county fair, as I have done for many years. This year, I judged almost exclusively paper crafts, including scrapbook pages, cards, mini albums, quilling, and more. It was equal parts fun, difficult and exhausting.


Odd things often happen to me when I judge. Last year's... um... infestation... was, well, memorable. This year, a stranger who was judging something completely different than me in a different building came right up to me, her face inches from mine, and demanded to know, "Are you the gourd judge?!" I was unsure how to answer, as I was not exactly clear on what she was talking about. She took my confused silence as a negative, issuing the parting comment, "Let me know if you find out who the gourd judge is!" Um... sure. Will do. I never learned who the gourd judge was or what business this other judge had related to gourds.

In 2013, after completing my judging I felt compelled to write an open letter to fair contestants. You can read that here. I wrote another letter last year, which is here. Today I'm sharing "Dear Entrants,..." Part Three.

-------

Dear Entrants,

Thank you so much for entering your projects in the county fair! I appreciate that all of you have taken the time and made the effort to share your creations with us. It's your support that has kept our fair thriving for generations.

Judging at the fair is hard work. I do it because I love fairs, enjoy seeing the many talents in our area, and like using my expertise to ensure that your efforts are judged fairly and honestly. (Of course, I never turn down the money or the free lunch either!) I've been judging for many, many years and this was the most difficult year by far. Why? Well, imagine looking at 12 beautiful apples, that all look perfect at first glance, with the task of accurately identifying the three very best. I might not think Golden Delicious is as inherently pretty or tasty as Fuji, but does that mean that a perfect Golden Delicious should always lose to a Fuji? Of course not. Instead, I have to find the tiniest flaw that makes one objectively better in some way than another. It's not easy.

Entrants, your projects were like the seemingly-perfect apples. I had to put aside my personal taste and look for the tiniest details (perfectly straight cuts, pristine projects, not a trace of visible adhesive, etc) in order to rank your projects. There weren't any rotten apples in the bunch that I could immediately rule out. No- I was blown away by the quality of the entries this year. You've outdone yourselves in terms of creativity, workmanship and attention to detail.

You listened to what your judge told you last year. Not one of you turned in a sticky project. Nothing was infested (*shudder*). Glue gun strings were practically non-existent. No one submitted an offensive or inappropriate project. Thank you. Even though you made my job harder, I greatly appreciate it.

I can't wait to see what you submit next year!

Sincerely,
Your Judge

10 comments:

  1. Awesome! Glad to hear that the input was taken and applied!!!! And Adam and Brookie both miss each other! She uses Daddy's phone to text him :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. So great that they actually took your advice...and that your advice made for better projects!
    The "gourd judge incident"... a cliffhanger I'm curious to know the ending to! Don't forget to update us if you ever find out!

    BTW (based on your comment on my latest blog post)- I could never read the "Girl w/ The Dragon Tattoo" series. After watching the movie based on the first book, I was sick to my stomach...literally! The violence was way too much for me. If you ever get a chance to see it, I don't recommend it for the sheer "sickness" of it. But since you read the book I'm sure you know what I'm talking about.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't watch a lot of movies... maybe 2 a year. And in general, I don't watch movies where I read and enjoyed the book(s) first unless I hear repeatedly that the movie was worth seeing and didn't ruin the book.

      Delete
  3. Every time I read one of your posts about the county fair, I long to have one here. It would be fun to enter, or have Cory enter, and, just maybe, it would be fun to judge. We do not have a fair in my county (large metropolitan city) but there are fairs in the two counties north of us. Don't think I would be eligible for those, but I have been to them. Always interesting to see the paper-crafting entries! Happy to hear the entries at your fair were nicely executed this year!

    ReplyDelete
  4. You might be eligible. We can enter in something like 9 counties besides our own.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm really glad that there were no infestations this time! LOL I love reading your letters to the entrants every year.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yay for no infestations! And it's good that everyone listened to you, Cindy! I love reading your blog posts - you amaze me each and every time.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Cindy, I have a question, One of the "classes" that you can enter for a scrapbook page at our fair is to use the same picture multiple times. Would you consider it the same picture if two of the same print are black & white and the 3rd print of the same picture is in color? thanks, Pam Bauer

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I'd definitely say that's the same photo. You can check with your county fair's Exhibits Coordinator just to make sure though. :)

      Delete
    2. Thank you!! Pam

      Delete