It was tight, but I managed to complete two cards using all the requirements and enter them before the end of the BYSS World Series, Game 3.
Hello Again cards (affiliate link)
As you can see, each card has a tag, ribbon, washi tape, a critter (butterfly), and a doodled border. That's another grand slam for the Banshees!
I used the Hello Again collection by Doodlebug Design, which I recently won by commenting on the Doodlebug blog. The collection has small tags that fit perfectly on cards and plenty of critters (butterflies), so it was a great choice for this challenge.