The Top 10 Jewish...

My friend (and former dance partner) Adam Diament is incredibly awesome. What I love most about Adam is that he is always challenging himself, always learning (he has a PhD and a law degree), and is always accomplishing something new. I blogged about him and his super cool counties project here. His latest project was writing a book.

The Top 10 Jewish... contains over 100 ranked lists, ranging from the Top 10 Jewish Summer Olympians (Marc Spitz, Mitch Gaylord, Kerri Strug), the Top 10 Peculiar Commandments ("Do not destroy fruit trees, even in time of war"), and the Top 10 Gentiles Who Seem Jewish (Joy Behar, Jason Biggs, Robin Williams). The lists were fascinating.  Some were informative, some controversial, and some hilarious. Many prompted me to head to Google to learn more.

But of all the lists, the one that interested me the most was the Top 10 Jewish Foods. When I made my list of 40 Things, I decided that one of the things I wanted to do was try any of the foods on the list that I hadn't had before.

In case it isn't obvious, I'm not Jewish. But between my years of studying the Old Testament in Sunday School and an incredibly challenging Jewish Studies course in college, I feel like I have a general idea of the basics. I've attended three Jewish weddings (including Adam's), I've been to a seder, and I was at a friend's baby-naming ceremony at a synagogue, so I've had a number of opportunities to eat Jewish food. But there were still a few foods on the list that I had never tried. So, without further ado, here is my attempt to eat the Top 10 Jewish Foods.

Top 10 Jewish Foods

1. Latkes
I've had latkes before many times. I've made them several times. They are, in a word, delicious.

2. Matzah ball soup
Believe it or not, I had never tried matzah ball soup until last month! I've always wanted to try it but never specifically made plans to make it or seek it out. We recently ate at a New York style deli and there it was on the menu. It was so good!

3. Bagels, lox, and cream cheese
I *love* bagels, with or without cream cheese. Lox, no. I've tried it before - a teeny, tiny, itty bite to get someone off my case about not trying it. I am open to trying most foods, but there are two categories that repulse me: insects and seafood. If you gave me a choice between eating a cockroach or eating catfish, it would be a tough decision. There's a good chance I'd choose the insect, as the thought of seafood absolutely nauseates me.

People always assume I grew up in a family that didn't eat seafood. Sadly, that is not the case. My parents love it and we had seafood at least once a week growing up. I was repulsed by it then and continue to be repulsed 40 years later. "But _____ is so good!" people tell me. I don't care. It's disgusting and shouldn't be a food and I don't want to eat it. I hear that grasshoppers are tasty, but I have no more interest in trying your calamari or salmon or mussels or trout than I would in trying your plate of grasshoppers, beetles, moths, or crickets. I have eaten a tiny bite of every seafood that exists to get people off my case. (A surprising number of people over the years have been bothered by my not eating seafood.)

4. Challah
What's not to love about challah? Bread is my favorite food, so of course I've had challah many times. I've made it once or twice as well.

5. Knish
I had a vague idea of what a knish was when I read the Top 10 list, but I'd never had one. I did a bunch of research and chose this recipe to make my own. There were a lot of steps - making the dough, making mashed potatoes (enter the Rotato!), rolling out the dough, filling and shaping the dough, then finally baking. At one point, I swore I'd never make them again no matter how good they tasted. But then I actually tasted the finished product. They were absolutely delicious. Imagine a thin, biscuit-like crust surrounding smooth and rich mashed potatoes. Fantastic. I'd planned to freeze the leftover knishes but we ended up eating them for dinner three nights in a row. Yum.

6. Gefilte Fish
I can't swear that I've tried gefilte fish, but it's highly probable (see #3). If I've never actually tried it, oh well. I will not be eating it in the future.

7. Hamentashen
When I first read the list, I had to Google hamentashen to find out what it was. Turns out it's a triangular-shaped cookie with a fruit filling. I *might* have had them before, but unlike the gefilte fish, I'm more than willing to try it again just to be sure. After reading a bunch of recipes, I chose this one to make. I added lemon zest to the dough (most of the other recipes suggested that) and used raspberry jam as the filling. They were SO good.

8. Matzah brei
Back to Google for this one. I know what matzah is, obviously, but I didn't know about the brei part. Well, it turns out brei means "fried" and that matzah brei is essentially softened matzah in scrambled eggs. I like matzah and I like scrambled eggs. As I read on, I learned that there are two factions when it comes to matzah brei: those who like a savory version with onions and those who like a sweet version with cinnamon sugar or jam. Wait, what?! Cinnamon sugar on scrambled eggs?! Sounds like crazy-talk.

I was wary about the sweet version and decided I was firmly in the savory camp. But the more that I thought about it, the more I realized I needed to try both versions since they are equally popular. I announced to my ever-tolerant family that we'd be having matzah brei for both dinner and dessert. Neither my husband nor my son was particularly enthusiastic.

Following these recipes, I carmelized some onions, soaked some matzah in water, and added both to eggs. A little salt and pepper, then I scrambled them up and served them for dinner.

I thought it was pretty good. Steve and Trevor both picked at it, but eventually ate it and declared it ok. Then I returned to the stove to make the sweet version. This time, I soaked the matzah in milk, added a pinch of sugar, cracked in eggs, and scrambled that up. I got out raspberry jam and cinnamon sugar. I tried both the jam.....

.... and the cinnamon sugar.

I was worried that sweet eggs with mushy crackers in it would be awful, but I actually loved it. The jam was good, but the cinnamon sugar was outstanding. Trevor agreed and ate every bite. Steve had the opposite experience. He could barely choke down the three small bites I'd served him. He absolutely hated it. Of course, he doesn't have a sweet tooth, while Trevor and I love anything and everything sweet.

9.  Falafel
I've had falafel a handful of times. I like it. I've never made them though - something to try in the near future.

10.  Hummus
I've had hummus many times and like it too.

So there you go! Goal #33 accomplished, just in time for (C)han(n)uk(k)a(h)! (You can find out the Top 10 Ways to Spell (C)han(n)uk(k)a(h) on page 5 of Adam's book.)  Thanks to Adam for the awesome book and the inspiration for this goal. I strongly recommend his book to any of you, Jewish or not. It's a really fun and interesting read!


  1. It all sounds delicious!! I love that you are so adventurous with your food. I can honestly say I haven't tried 1/4 of those things.

  2. Thanks for the plug Cindy. Although the sweet version of Matzah Brei sounds weird, just think of it like french toast, but with unleavened bread (matzah) It's really not much different than that. Gefilte Fish is one of those things where there's no middle ground and I think you have to be brought up on it. Even then, it's not for everyone. As for Latkes, they're number 1 in my book, but there is debate on whether Hamantashen should be number 1. See The great latke-hamantash debate here, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latke-Hamantash_Debate.


  3. Oh wow. They all sound delicious! I've a sweet tooth too!

  4. I need to check out his book!!!! And that does sound yummy!!! I grew up in NYC -- so I have tried a lot of those foods!! :)

  5. That book sounds fun! I added it to my wishlist!

    Is it ok if I don't know what knish is? LOL I am sure if you would ask 10 Jews you will get at least 15 versions of the the top 10 Jewish foods. I myself can give you at least three lists ;-) Good for you for trying new things!
    BTW, from the food you included in your list, gefilte fish is number one in my book. But as Adam said you have to be brought up on it. My DH, who is a Sephardic Jew can not stand it.

  6. I think all these foods sound wonderful. There's probably half I haven't tried and need to!

    For most of my life, I wouldn't go near fish (as a food) with a 10-foot pole. Bleck! Then one day (around age 30) I tried it again after being pushed and cajoled. Oh my goodness, I LOVED it. I eat seafood all the time now, especially fish, and I make a mean fish chowder. Catfish is super duper tasty, I promise. Really. No fingers crossed or anything. Try something like pan fried Talapia coated with bread crumbs/parm cheese. Very mild and oh so yummy. You won't believe you hated it all these years. Promise.

    1. You'll never convince me. In addition to being completely disgusted by the concept of sea creatures as food, I don't like the taste of any that I have ever tried, which includes catfish and tilapia. Last week I tried branzino for the first time (breaded and fried) and it was hideous. Ugh.


I moderate comments, so you will not see yours appear right away. Please check back if you had a question; I promise to answer it as soon as I see it. Thank you for taking the time to comment!